Overview
ABSTRACT
The question that runs through this article is simple but fundamental : is auditing really the ideal analytical tool for understanding how an organization functions ?
Answering this question is already a step towards reinventing auditing.
This article proposes to open a path that starts from a so-called classic audit (such as a compliance audit) towards a more lucid, more demanding, and perhaps also more accurate analysis – a path that leads to congruence analysis.
Read this article from a comprehensive knowledge base, updated and supplemented with articles reviewed by scientific committees.
Read the articleAUTHOR
-
Michel JONQUIERES : Founding Member of the Academy of Ethics and CICCAS (International Center for Certification of Competencies in Social Auditing)
INTRODUCTION
In an environment marked by the growing complexity of organizations, the acceleration of change, and increasing demands for transparency, analytical tools play a strategic role. Long structured around the principles of control, compliance, and performance measurement, these tools are now faced with a broader expectation: to account not only for what is done, but also for what it actually produces, within open, interdependent, and evolving systems.
This shift highlights a crisis of relevance for traditional systems.
While compliance audits remain essential for ensuring the security and reliability of procedures, they struggle to capture the complex, delayed, or indirect effects of actions. For their part, evaluative approaches, which focus on impacts, provide a more dynamic understanding, but sometimes at the cost of less standardization (*) and difficulty integrating into existing frameworks. These limitations reveal not so much an intrinsic shortcoming of the tools as a lack of coordination between analytical frameworks that have remained too compartmentalized for too long.
Consequently, the central question becomes that of their integration: how can we move beyond the dichotomy between control and understanding, between compliance and impact, to build analytical frameworks capable of capturing both the rigor of processes and the reality of the effects produced?
This article aims to address this issue by exploring the conditions for a gradual convergence between auditing, impact assessment, the combination of auditing and assessment, and, beyond that, congruence analysis.
The approach adopted is both conceptual and methodological. It is based on a critical analysis of existing frameworks, enriched by an examination of hybrid practices and emerging dynamics. The article thus adopts a cross-cutting perspective, at the intersection of control, evaluation, and strategic management, with the aim of proposing an evolving framework for interpreting analytical tools. More than a simple inventory of the current state of affairs, it seeks to outline the contours of a paradigm shift, grounded in an integrated, systemic, and goal-oriented understanding of the actions under analysis.
Exclusive to subscribers. 97% yet to be discovered!
Already subscribed? Log in!
KEYWORDS
evolution | audit | conformity assessment | congruence analysis
Prospects for the evolution of analysis systems - Understanding the new forms of auditing, evaluation and analysis
Bibliography
Also in our database
Standards and norms
ISO – Standards relating to risk management (ISO 31000), governance (ISO 37000), and information systems (ISO 27001).
OECD, Work related to governance, public policy, and artificial intelligence.
Exclusive to subscribers. 97% yet to be discovered!
Already subscribed? Log in!
Article included in this offer
"Industrial management"
(
79 articles
)
Updated and enriched with articles validated by our scientific committees
A set of exclusive tools to complement the resources