Overview
ABSTRACT
The fundamental question to ask is : is it really possible to audit ethical "matter" ?
A positive answer to this question undoubtedly deserves well-argued and well-constructed development !
In itself this questioning has little meaning; it seems possible to audit the ethics of manufacturing a product, the operation of a service or activity or even to audit the implementation of a management system (just as it is possible to audit the quality of these elements), on the other hand it does not seem possible to audit an individual, nor his ethical behavior, at most one could talk to assess his ethical behavior.
Paragraph 3.1 of standard NF EN ISO 19011: 2018 specifies that an audit is a "methodical, independent and documented process, making it possible to obtain objective evidence and to evaluate it objectively to determine to what extent the criteria of audit are satisfied ”.
Auditing the ethical "matter" therefore presupposes the prior existence of a set of auditable criteria, requirements (aka the ethical audit reference system).
The development of a benchmark essential to the practice of auditing ethics leads to identifying and compiling the values, the requirements, the principles chosen by an organization within laws, regulations, charters, conventions, standards and other texts.
Read this article from a comprehensive knowledge base, updated and supplemented with articles reviewed by scientific committees.
Read the articleAUTHOR
-
Michel JONQUIERES : Vice-President, Académie de l'Ethique, Paris - Vice-President, IAS (International Institute of Social Auditing), Paris
INTRODUCTION
Is it realistic to think we can audit ethics?
It seems difficult to audit values or principles, just as it seems difficult to audit morals. On the other hand, auditing an organization's ethical behavior seems an achievable mission.
Having explored the meaning of the various terms used above, a first question arises: should we speak of ethics auditing or ethics evaluation?
A second question arises: auditing requires the development of a set of specified (and auditable) requirements. On the basis of these requirements, it will be possible to ensure compliance with them: the audit can be carried out.
The term "ethical culture" plays a key role in this ethics audit approach, opening the door to audits of compliance, efficiency and strategy in the field of ethics.
The same applies to the term "ethical risk": is the management system in place capable of controlling all the ethical risks associated with the organization's operations?
To conclude this development, it is necessary to look at ethics auditors: are they auditors "like any others" or do they need specific skills?
Exclusive to subscribers. 97% yet to be discovered!
Already subscribed? Log in!
KEYWORDS
ethics | audit | management | values
Ethics audit
Prolegomena
Article included in this offer
"Eco-design and sustainable innovation"
(
136 articles
)
Updated and enriched with articles validated by our scientific committees
A set of exclusive tools to complement the resources
Bibliography
Exclusive to subscribers. 97% yet to be discovered!
Already subscribed? Log in!
